Search

Bishops’ letter over government’s gay marriage consultation

15:45 27 April 2012

Bishop of Norwich, the Rt Rev Graham James, during a rededication of St Andrews church, Lowestoft.

Bishop of Norwich, the Rt Rev Graham James, during a rededication of St Andrews church, Lowestoft.

Archant © 2011

Three Anglican bishops have written to their congregations about their views on the issue of gay marriage.

The letter was sent from the Rt Rev Graham James, Bishop of Norwich, the Rt Rev Alan Winton, Bishop of Thetford, and the Rt Rev Jonathan Meyrick, Bishop of Lynn.

It was written on behalf of the Diocese of Norwich to its clergy on Thursday.

The government launched its 12-week consultation on allowing gay couples in England and Wales to marry in a register office or other civil ceremony last month. It will close on June 14.

Part of the letter from the bishops said: “The consultation document says very little about marriage itself and does not seek to define it.

“Nevertheless, it does speak of civil marriage and religious marriage as if these are two entirely separate concepts.”

It went on to say that “an unhealthy and damaging division” between civil and religious marriages could be created because of the Church of England’s lack of provision to marry same sex couples.

On Monday, the EDP reported that the Dean of Norwich had urged the Church of England not block its ears and close its eyes over the government’s proposal.

The Very Rev Graham Smith was among clergy who signed a letter in a national newspaper on Saturday which said the Church should “rejoice” at the prospect of gay marriage.

The bishops’ letter added: “We believe this consultation is too narrowly focused and too predetermined to animate the sort of public debate about the nature of marriage which our society needs.”

But it said there seemed to be a good deal of confusion surrounding marriage itself.

The bishops believed it was important to avoid “ill-considered reactions” to the government’s proposals.

“It is surely to the benefit of the whole of our society if gay people live in faithful, stable and publicly recognised relationships. Indeed, some gay relationships are a model of faithfulness compared with the serial monogamy so prevalent among hetrosexual people,” the letter said.

To view the full letter from the three bishops visit www.edp24.co.uk

The government’s consultation document can be viewed by visiting www.homeoffice.gov.uk/equal-civil-marriage

Related articles

4 comments

  • Civil partnership and marriage are not the same and I personally do not agree with the notion of same gender couples being allowed to marry. Marriage is meant for the intention of procreation. Biologically, this is not possibly in same gender couples, any more than men wishing to give birth. If we are to advance this argument, then we may as well abolish the "mothers" and "fathers" and replace with a generic "parents" label. Likewise, who is an aunt, but would prefer to be called uncle and vice versa?

    Report this comment

    Musto_Fan

    Friday, April 27, 2012

  • i agree Elton John has always made me feel ill as well--before during and after his 2 marriages.

    Report this comment

    bookworm

    Sunday, April 29, 2012

  • Heterosexual couples should be allowed to marry even if they do not or cannot have children. Biologically, the only way to procreate involves a man and a woman. Marriage has a unique definition and this should rightly remain as it is now - for a man and woman whose biological organs are intended for procreation, even if they can't have children, which is a separate issue from the obvious point as to why homosexuals can't procreate with each other. Besides, homosexual couples have civil partnership, something not available to heterosexual couples. Of course, any couple should be allowed to take up with whoever they live. I have no interest in what *anyone* does in bed and with whom. However, I do not agree with homosexual people marrying, when they have civil partnership any more than I wish for females to stand next to males to urinate in a public lavatory.

    Report this comment

    Musto_Fan

    Tuesday, May 1, 2012

  • So Musto_Fan, does that mean that couples that cannot or choose not to procreate should not be allowed to marry either? It is biologically not possible for a huge number of couples to have children regardless of their gender but I don't see that it has anything to do with marriage. What is you reasoning behind aboloshing "father" and "mother"? Surely a child with two male parents would have 2 fathers - many, many people bring up their children alone for whatever reason and as such, their children may only have a mother OR a father and not both. To me, mariage is about love, commitment and wanting to celebrate this. I don't see how anybody's gender has anything to do with it.

    Report this comment

    Linds

    Monday, April 30, 2012

The views expressed in the above comments do not necessarily reflect the views of this site

Other news

Yesterday, 06:30
John and Brenda Foster have raised more than £40,000 for the National Garden Scheme over the past 38 years and are inviting visitors to view their display of snowdrops this weekend. 

PHOTO: Nick Butcher

They have raised thousands for charity by sharing their garden with the public.

Yesterday, 06:30
Diamond Wedding Couple Derek and Bridget Jermy from Loddon.

PHOTO: Nick Butcher

A couple celebrating 60 years of marriage have said their secret to happiness is doing things together.

Yesterday, 06:30
Ian Eaton presenting the cheque for £23,310.79 to staff at the Sandra Chapman Centre at the James Paget Hospital in Gorleston.

A Beccles man who climbed three mountains and cycled over 1,200 miles in the space of two weeks, has raised £23,000 for the treatment centre that cared for his late wife.

Thu, 19:00
Warren Candler (pub manager). 

PHOTO: Nick Butcher

The Suffolk town of Bungay was once home to dozens of pubs, with a different one for every day of the month.

Most Read

Thu, 19:00
Warren Candler (pub manager). 

PHOTO: Nick Butcher

The Suffolk town of Bungay was once home to dozens of pubs, with a different one for every day of the month.

Read more
Bungay
Thursday, July 9, 2015
The painting of Florence Carter-Wood titled Portrait of Florence Munnings at Sunset.

An oil painting of Sir Alfred Munnings’ first wife, who committed suicide at the age of 25 after being parted from her secret lover, is up for sale at £185,000 in London.

Read more
United Kingdom
Yesterday, 06:30
Ian Eaton presenting the cheque for £23,310.79 to staff at the Sandra Chapman Centre at the James Paget Hospital in Gorleston.

A Beccles man who climbed three mountains and cycled over 1,200 miles in the space of two weeks, has raised £23,000 for the treatment centre that cared for his late wife.

Read more
James Paget Hospital
Thu, 17:47

A pedestrian in her 70s was airlifted to hospital with serious head injuries after a collision with a car in Ellingham near Bungay this morning.

Read more
Yesterday, 06:30
John and Brenda Foster have raised more than £40,000 for the National Garden Scheme over the past 38 years and are inviting visitors to view their display of snowdrops this weekend. 

PHOTO: Nick Butcher

They have raised thousands for charity by sharing their garden with the public.

Read more
Macmillan

Local Weather

Partly Cloudy

Partly Cloudy

max temp: 6°C

min temp: 3°C

HOT JOBS

Show Job Lists

Digital Edition

Image
Read the Beccles and Bungay Journal e-edition today E-edition