Mick McCarthy, Paul Lambert and the art of instruction

11:08 20 February 2012


Let's get physica - City's midfield powerhouse Wes Hoolahan helps kick Swansea off the park by daring to make contact with Leon Britton. Photo: Paul Chesterton/Focus Images

Given one chant from the Barclay, I suspect the rest of this paragraph isn’t going to generate much of a warm glow in these parts – but I feel sympathy for those banner-loving fans at Molineux.

Just saying…

• Other than the clear mutual respect Brendan Rodgers and Paul Lambert enjoy, there seems to be an edge to City and Swansea. I enjoy the Swans’ style but they’ve taken a few ‘Swanselona’ traits too far. Danny Graham couldn’t stay on his feet, regardless of contact, while the whole ground seemed to have banned any form of tackling at football played in south Wales. And as for Nathan Dyer’s post-match comments?… “We maybe didn’t get as much protection as we would’ve liked – there were a few too many kicks…we’re not the type of team to be crowding the referee so maybe we’re a bit naïve in not protesting as much as we should.” Had City crowded the officials at any point on Saturday, Dyer may have a point. But he doesn’t, and Swansea had better be careful no one really goes out to kick them off the park any time soon.

• I like Harry Redknapp a lot – don’t we all – but the great man-motivator couldn’t get as much as a peep out of Steven Pienaar, Everton’s saviour. Best remember ‘Arry’s only human, before he takes over our beloved England stars.

Or maybe it’s Mick McCarthy I feel for, rather than Wolves. McCarthy has had a tough time of it this season as the self-asserted ‘sleeping giants’ of English football saw their significant development and improvement plateau with top-flight relegation struggles.

It is an ongoing issue with domestic football at the moment – all sides outside the big hitters start every season trying to prolong their Premier League status. This season we’ve all tasted what top-flight football means – clearly, it is the only place to be.

I personally think McCarthy would have kept Wolves up.

But that wasn’t what saw him kicked out – that was the manner of Sunday’s 5-1 home defeat to their fierce rivals.

You can only imagine what the Baggies felt that day. Or take yourself back to Thursday, April 21, if you like. Whatever’s easiest.

Wolves looked lost on Sunday; devoid of any confidence and completely clueless over what their individual jobs were or how to go about them.

No doubt there was a plan devised during the week – but McCarthy’s men could not put it into practice.

If you are a struggling side, that failure do turn a tactics board into three points is a regular occurrence. We all saw that at Norwich before Paul Lambert’s arrival, under various managers and groups of players.

And it is worth highlighting – given that under the current manager, it is rare any player looks unsure over what their role is or the team then fails to deliver.

Don’t forget, this isn’t a group that turns up with ‘their’ game and ‘the’ formation every week. The press room – like the stands – awaits the pre-match team sheet in a similar way to tucking into a Kinder egg.

Andrew Surman answered my question at Colney before City’s game at Swansea – and made the work of Lambert and Ian Culverhouse on the training ground and in meetings in the Colney mobiles sound very easy.

“We work a lot in the week on what we’re going to do on a Saturday so that anyone that comes in knows their job,” said Surman. “The manager makes sure he gets his point across; Cully as well.

“If you don’t understand, they are there to talk to and ask questions, and I suppose both have got experience as players as well.

“It’s a key thing this season. I’ll mention Benno (Elliott Bennett). He went in at right-back, knew what to do and knew his job, and I think everyone playing this season has gone out and done that.”

In some ways footballers are simple folk. Make them feel like world-beaters and those brick walls won’t stand a chance.

But there is a knack to communicating relentlessly changing plans and instructions to your group of players that they understand and almost always follow to the letter.

It’s what the game outside England thrives on – especially in major championships. It’s what has made Sir Alex Ferguson’s success so long and so fruitful and Old Trafford.

And in truth, it is what sets apart Mick McCarthy and his ex-Wolves from Paul Lambert.

Related articles


  • It's all the behind the scenes hard work by Cully and Lambo that makes a major contribution to City's success. Long may they reign.

    Report this comment


    Wednesday, February 22, 2012

  • I agree, in the end it is the simple stuff that counts and there is nothing so encouraging as working with a group that you know that you can rely on.

    Report this comment

    Swiss Canary

    Wednesday, February 22, 2012

  • It is also helpful that the players trust and believe in their manager coaches. Just take a peek at Chelski to see what can happen even with 'good' footballers who have lost belief.

    Report this comment

    Soglio Star

    Wednesday, February 22, 2012

The views expressed in the above comments do not necessarily reflect the views of this site

Other news

10 minutes ago
The Rev Rich Henderson is the new priest in charge of the parish of Beccles.

The Rev Rich Henderson is stepping into a new role, but it will be in familiar territory for the former Beccles curate.

10 minutes ago
Bact community transport which has won a five-year contract from Suffolk County Council.

A Beccles and Bungay volunteer service will now be responsible for rural transport in all of Waveney.

Yesterday, 06:30
John and Brenda Foster have raised more than £40,000 for the National Garden Scheme over the past 38 years and are inviting visitors to view their display of snowdrops this weekend. 

PHOTO: Nick Butcher

They have raised thousands for charity by sharing their garden with the public.

Yesterday, 06:30
Diamond Wedding Couple Derek and Bridget Jermy from Loddon.

PHOTO: Nick Butcher

A couple celebrating 60 years of marriage have said their secret to happiness is doing things together.

Most Read

Thu, 19:00
Warren Candler (pub manager). 

PHOTO: Nick Butcher

The Suffolk town of Bungay was once home to dozens of pubs, with a different one for every day of the month.

Read more
Thursday, July 9, 2015
The painting of Florence Carter-Wood titled Portrait of Florence Munnings at Sunset.

An oil painting of Sir Alfred Munnings’ first wife, who committed suicide at the age of 25 after being parted from her secret lover, is up for sale at £185,000 in London.

Read more
United Kingdom
Yesterday, 06:30
Ian Eaton presenting the cheque for £23,310.79 to staff at the Sandra Chapman Centre at the James Paget Hospital in Gorleston.

A Beccles man who climbed three mountains and cycled over 1,200 miles in the space of two weeks, has raised £23,000 for the treatment centre that cared for his late wife.

Read more
James Paget Hospital
Yesterday, 06:30
John and Brenda Foster have raised more than £40,000 for the National Garden Scheme over the past 38 years and are inviting visitors to view their display of snowdrops this weekend. 

PHOTO: Nick Butcher

They have raised thousands for charity by sharing their garden with the public.

Read more
Thu, 17:47

A pedestrian in her 70s was airlifted to hospital with serious head injuries after a collision with a car in Ellingham near Bungay this morning.

Read more

Local Weather

Partly Cloudy

Partly Cloudy

max temp: 4°C

min temp: 3°C


Show Job Lists

Digital Edition

Read the Beccles and Bungay Journal e-edition today E-edition